Muslim writer makes plain the desire to call people to activism while ignoring the real problem
Her call? It’s time to choose: Stand up
to hate or sink into division
Below are excerpts with responses to her declarations….
This is a watershed
moment in our nation’s history as we struggle to overcome racism, xenophobia,
Islamophobia, misogyny, etc. Normally, we Americans could expect our president,
the leader of our nation, to be at the forefront of this struggle, lighting the
way toward a brighter future for all Americans. Instead, our president has
chosen to produce and amplify messages of hate, marginalization and division,
tearing our nation apart.
First, she misrepresents
the moment as compared to U.S. history. The watershed is the invasion of
Muslims that refuse to become a part of the American Culture. Secondly, she
lies about Trump as the cause. In his words and behavior, he is not.
We have all
seen more than the usual level of prejudice over the past three years,
targeting nearly every minority community. American Muslim families have borne
the brunt of this bigotry for more than a decade.
Here, she admits a lot of
her complaints pre-date Trump.
The effect on
all minority communities has been huge increases in discrimination, hate crimes
and the bullying of children. The negative effect on the future of our nation,
our families and communities is hard to overestimate.
Again, a vacant
declaration. No citations or supporting data.
So, what are
we, as fair-minded Americans, to do? In circumstances like these, it’s up to
each one of us to set examples with our own actions and help lead the way
toward a better future, for our families, our communities and our nation. While
those who spread hatred and division claim their right to free speech, we must
choose to firmly grasp our own freedom of speech to turn back the tide of
negativity that threatens to engulf us all.
I’ve listened to this
woman and what she has written for a number of years. It is Free Speech that
allows this. CAIR (she is one of their executive directors) has been declared to
be exactly what she says is wrong. Speech keeps us free!
Every one of
us, as fair-minded Americans, can use our freedom of speech to inspire our
fellow Americans to be their best selves.
So, if you agree with her
you are fair-minded. If not, sorry, you must not be fair! She completely ignores
the foundation of our country that is clearly spelled out in the Declaration of
Independence. The love for and the commitment to those principles and truths
called out is what makes us uniquely Americans!
Our voices,
amplified through media and other platforms, can help inspire millions of
fair-minded fellow Americans to do their part to build inclusive communities,
to find solutions to the challenges of the future. We all have talents,
abilities, ideas and networks that we can and must use to start repairing the
damage that has been done to the fabric of our nation. It can’t wait until next
month or next year. Each of us can start by visiting a mosque, a synagogue or a
church of a different denomination so that we can truly get to know one
another. Then, we can inspire our fellow Americans to also do the same by
talking to family, friends, neighbors and co-workers, and by using social media
to reach beyond those circles.
One’s religion or any other
factor really comes into play in her world view. It is not simply thoughts, it
is behavior. When one or more people kill large numbers of innocents, we judge
the behavior. If those responsible, claim a particular allegiance, we judge
that as well.
This country is
our home, and it is one of the most beautiful, and beautifully diverse, places
in God’s amazing creation. I truly believe that if we can all work together and
raise our voices for good, we can help make it the best it can be.
Again, she ignores the harsh
reality of what is going on in our nation and others. Muslims are arriving and
not assimilating into the American Culture. They demand Sharia Law and want our Nation to
bend to Islamic belief. Going to a Mosque or another person’s place of worship
will not change that. How can we be one nation if we have those that come in
(some say invade) to our countries and refuse to assimilate?
CAIR may be what they are
accused of being. That is not my purpose here. I have read the Koran and know the Bible. I can find no way these two beliefs can co-exist; for one is
diametrically opposed to the other in all ways.
Karen Dabdoub
is executive director of the Cincinnati office of the Council on
American-Islamic Relations, America’s largest American Muslim civil rights
organization wrote the above article.